

Image source: Block Media
Arthur Hayes: The Demise of Bitcoin’s Four-Year Cycle in Favor of Global Liquidity Trends
Arthur Hayes, the former CEO of BitMEX, has put forth a bold claim that the long-standing notion of Bitcoin’s four-year halving cycle is now outdated. Hayes posits that Bitcoin’s price movements, once heavily associated with its halving events, are increasingly dictated by shifts in global liquidity. He expressed this view in a blog post, as reported by U.Today on October 9, asserting that monetary policies and liquidity conditions now wield more influence over Bitcoin’s trajectory than any predefined calendar cycles.
The Core Argument: Liquidity Outweighs Bitcoin’s Halving Cycle
Hayes argues that Bitcoin’s price surges and corrections have historically been influenced more by unique liquidity circumstances in each cycle than by the halving mechanism itself. With the current financial landscape dominated by evolving global monetary dynamics, he believes that liquidity shifts—both expansive and restrictive—will play the decisive role in shaping Bitcoin’s market performance moving forward. This marks a departure from the previously accepted narrative that each Bitcoin rally closely follows the reduction in mining rewards every four years.
Historical Context: How Liquidity Shaped Bitcoin’s Past Bull Markets
To support his argument, Hayes delves into the historical role of liquidity in Bitcoin’s previous bull runs:
-
2009–2013: The first Bitcoin bull cycle coincided with the aftermath of the global financial crisis. During this period, the United States employed aggressive quantitative easing (QE) measures, injecting significant liquidity into the economy. This created fertile ground for Bitcoin’s early surge as it emerged as an alternative financial asset.
-
2017: The second major bull run took place during a period of massive credit expansion in China. As China’s financial sector pumped liquidity into its domestic economy, global markets, including Bitcoin, benefited. However, Bitcoin’s rally came to an end as China’s rapid credit growth began to decelerate.
-
2021: The most recent major bull cycle was driven by an unprecedented wave of fiscal stimulus in response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Trillions of dollars were distributed globally in emergency stimulus measures, spurring market-wide optimism and fueling Bitcoin’s rise. However, the Federal Reserve’s pivot to a restrictive monetary policy in 2022 abruptly curtailed the cryptocurrency market’s upward momentum.
The Current Environment: Diverging Global Monetary Policies
Hayes identifies the present global liquidity environment as a complex and divergent one. In the United States, the government remains committed to policies aimed at sustaining liquidity expansion. Meanwhile, China has adopted a more cautious stance, limiting its credit growth. This divergence underscores the growing importance of global monetary flows in influencing Bitcoin’s price.
In Hayes’ view, these liquidity fluctuations will overshadow any predictable patterns related to Bitcoin’s halving events. As central banks and governments continue to respond to economic challenges with nuanced and sometimes conflicting policy measures, Bitcoin’s sensitivity to these liquidity dynamics will likely intensify.
Disruptors to the Cycle: Bitcoin Spot ETFs and Structural Shifts
Another key factor disrupting Bitcoin’s historical cycles is the evolving structure of the cryptocurrency market itself. The advent of Bitcoin spot exchange-traded funds (ETFs) is a noteworthy development. Ki Young Ju, CEO of the on-chain analytics platform CryptoQuant, emphasizes this transition, noting that institutional adoption is changing the composition of market participants.
“The structure of the market has fundamentally changed,” Ki remarked. “Holders now outnumber traders.” This shift, fueled in part by institutional investments facilitated by spot ETFs, has significantly dampened Bitcoin’s cyclic price volatility. Institutional buyers, who traditionally favor holding assets long-term, are introducing stability to a market once dominated by short-term speculators.
The Road Ahead: A New Paradigm for the Cryptocurrency Market
As Bitcoin matures as a financial asset, its market dynamics are evolving in tandem. Liquidity trends, both global and regional, are gaining prominence as drivers of price movements. Simultaneously, structural changes—such as the impact of institutional inflows and the success of Bitcoin ETFs—are reshaping the market’s composition and reducing its susceptibility to cyclical behaviors.
Hayes’ insights signal the potential end of Bitcoin’s reliance on its halving cycle as the primary narrative for price prediction. Instead, investors and market participants may need to focus increasingly on macroeconomic indicators, central bank policies, and liquidity trends to navigate the cryptocurrency’s new era. As the ecosystem evolves, a blend of fiscal strategies and market structural developments will likely dictate Bitcoin’s future trajectory.